Smith: more ways than one to vote on the Desert EDGE

At the April 10 Scottsdale City Council meeting, I made a motion for council to discuss and consider seeking voter approval to issue bonds for up to 50 percent of the construction cost of a Desert Discovery Center or Desert EDGE, as it’s now known. No one else on council supported my motion.

David Smith

Don’t get me wrong … as the pragmatic financial member of council, I have many reservations about the DDC/DE as presented. I need to get comfortable with the total construction cost; I need to know how construction could be “staged.”

I need to know where a DDC/DE could be sited to have the best chance of success. I need to better understand the cost and benefit of partnering with ASU. I need to be sure the business plan is reasonable and attainable; and, if the business plan predicts an operating loss, I need to know where the operating subsidy will come from.

With this many open questions, why did I make a motion to seek citizen funding?

Consider this: the only matters a governmental body can “refer” to its voters are (1) legislative acts, (2) City Charter amendments or (3) tax issues.

The DDC/DE is not a legislative act — it’s only a proposal. Furthermore, a specific prohibition against construction of a DDC/DE cannot be drafted into City Charter language. Even the Charter language on the Protect Our Preserve petition being circulated only restricts construction in the Preserve as it says nothing about a DDC/DE that might be built elsewhere in our city.

The only way citizens can vote on a DDC/DE is with their pocketbooks. By saying they approve or refuse to pay for half the construction cost, they could have their voices heard.

Construction of the DDC/DE is estimated to cost $68 million, but we don’t have that kind of money at the city even if we dedicated all the carry-over cash and all the bonding capacity of the Tourism Development Fund.

Cash may accumulate in the Preserve Fund, but it is problematic whether these funds could be dedicated to a DDC/DE without voter approval. Several months ago, I crafted ballot language to ask for voter approval to spend Preserve fund money to partially fund construction of a DDC/DE. My council colleagues did not agree.

It may be premature to put a DDC/DE question on the ballot the way I suggested, but it would have given many voters the opportunity they seek: “a right to vote on the DDC!”

Editor’s note: Mr. Smith is a member of Scottsdale City Council

You are encouraged to leave relevant comments but engaging in personal attacks, threats, online bullying or commercial spam will not be allowed. All comments should remain within the bounds of fair play and civility. (You can disagree with others courteously, without being disagreeable.) Feel free to express yourself but keep an open mind toward finding value in what others say. To report abuse or spam, click the X in the upper right corner of the comment box.